Caught on the Antlers of a dilemma

On the 17th August, I had a fantastic night in the garden. The variety was the best for some time with 89 moths of 33 species. These included one year tick, one overdue garden tick and a further brand new species to me, as well as a potential second. The most stunning was an Antler Moth, a species that perhaps wandered from the heathland. The new garden species was two Yellow Shell - long overdue. But, better than that was a possible Hoary Footman. I personally cannot rule out a worn Scarce, so I would like your opinions.
.

17th August:

13 Dunbar

9 Shuttle-shaped Dart

8 LBBYU

7 Common Rustic sp.

6 Large Yellow Underwing

6 Copper Underwing

4 Vine's Rustic

4 Brimstone

3 Riband Wave

3 Svensson's Copper Underwing

3 Willow Beauty

2 Double-striped Pug

2 Yellow Shell NFG

1 Flame Shoulder

1 Small Rivulet

1 Maiden's Blush

1 Silver Y

1 Iron Prominent

1 Small Fan-footed Wave

1 Currant Pug

1 Common Carpet

1 Red Twin-spot Carpet

1 Yellow-barred Brindle

1 Turnip

1 Lesser Swallow Prominent

1 Cloaked Minor

1 Cabbage Moth

1 Pine Carpet NFY

1 Scalloped Oak

1 Antler Moth NFG

1 poss Hoary Footman NFG

.

Pine Carpet
Antler Moth
Hoary Footman?
View of underwing (I had to put my finger on it for it to unfurl its wings)
Yellow Shell